I second your love of the holidays and spice, and many of my favorite fragrances reflect this—Obsession, Jaipur, Michael Jordan Legend, and of course, Old Spice. 🙂
And maybe it’s the aging hippie in me, but I also love patchouli, and my other favorite scents tend to have a very refined patchouli base (Aramis, Polo Green, Quorum, Giorgio Beverly Hills PH).
